Just wanted to share my experience with Classic Exhaust Systems out of Madison, Ohio. Unfortunately, it hasn’t been a good one.

This isn’t my first time installing an exhaust system on a ‘64 Cadillac. I did one on my Sedan de Ville about 30 years ago. Interestingly enough, I had a problem with the Y-pipe back then too. The flanges didn’t line up properly with the exhaust manifolds, and I had to contact the company and have them send me a replacement. So I realize these systems aren’t always going to fit perfectly right out of the box, but what I went through this time was something else.

I purchased a complete exhaust system for my 1964 Cadillac on eBay back in August for about $1,100. The estimated delivery was 10 weeks, which worked out perfectly since the car was in the shop and wouldn’t be ready for the exhaust until October. Surprisingly, the system arrived in just three weeks. It was neatly packaged, so I left everything boxed up until I was ready to install it.

Now, I realize I might be the first guy to complain about getting something early, but that ended up being part of the problem.

When I finally unpacked everything, the first thing I noticed was that the muffler looked nothing like the one pictured in the listing. Instead of the long, skinny muffler used on ‘64 Cadillacs, it looked like a generic $30 Summit Racing muffler with a pipe welded onto it. The resonator was pretty much a joke too but at this point... I’m pretty particular about keeping things stock, but I decided to go ahead with the installation anyway. Especially given the fact that I already ripped out the old system.

That’s when the real problems started.

The Y-pipe bolted up perfectly to the exhaust manifolds, but the outlet was angled upward about 3–4 degrees. There was no way to install the muffler without practically cutting a hole in the floorboard!

I contacted the seller, sent pictures, and was told it was probably my motor mounts. Seriously? The engine would have to be tilted forward several degrees without affecting anything else!

He suggested taking the pipe to an exhaust shop to have it bent. I actually took it to two different shops, and both owners were very helpful. Unfortunately, both showed me that the pipe couldn’t be positioned in their bending machines to make the correction.

I eventually figured out my own way to bend the pipe downward and continued with the installation.

Next came the over-the-axle pipe. Once installed, the resonator pointed downward about four degrees instead of sitting neatly between the frame rail and gas tank. It ended up hanging almost directly underneath the frame rail.

More emails, more pictures, and more aggravation. To the seller’s credit, he eventually agreed to send a replacement over-the-axle pipe.

He also offered to send me the correct Cadillac muffler, explaining that the proper ones came from a supplier in Canada and were backordered. Unfortunately, when that muffler arrived, it was wrong too! It was too short, with an undersized body and inlet and outlet. It looked like something that might belong on a Chevy from the same era.

By this point, I’d had enough. When the replacement over-the-axle pipe arrived, I installed everything using the original generic muffler just to get the car back on the road.

And then came the biggest disappointment.

The system is ridiculously loud!

At idle, there’s a deep, low-frequency resonance coming from the tailpipe that vibrates through the entire car. It’s so loud you can barely carry on a conversation. Strangely enough, as soon as you give it some gas, the noise pretty much disappears though it's still pretty loud. It sounds like an old delivery truck.

I’ve checked thoroughly for leaks and made sure nothing is touching the frame or floorboards. I went through each an every exhaust hanger and located NOS ones or replaced the rubber in the originals. Everything is clear. It seems the muffler and resonator combination is hitting some sort of resonance at idle. Even standing behind the car, it's deafeningly loud and low. 

One of the things I love about these old Cadillacs is how quiet and smooth they are. This is the exact opposite.

I tried getting a refund through eBay, but because more than 30 days had passed since delivery, they wouldn’t help. I explained that the system had arrived seven weeks earlier than expected and that the car wasn’t available for installation until October, but it made no difference.

I also sent the seller a final email explaining how disappointed I was, but so far I haven’t received a response.

To be fair, the seller did make an effort by sending replacement parts, and I appreciate that. But after multiple fitment problems, two incorrect mufflers, countless emails and pictures, and hours spent modifying parts that should have fit correctly in the first place, I’m left with an exhaust system I’m completely unhappy with.

I’ve considered taking the car to a muffler shop and having them replace the muffler and resonator to see if that would quiet things down. But frankly, after everything I’ve already been through, I just don’t feel like spending any more money trying to make this system work.

At this point, I’m basically looking at $1,100 down the toilet. That’s a lot of money for something that was supposed to be a direct-fit exhaust system.

One other interesting thing: I went back through the seller’s negative feedback on eBay and noticed that one of the other complaints was also for an exhaust system for a 1964 Cadillac. I don’t know the details of that buyer’s experience, but it certainly caught my attention.

For now, I guess I’ll live with it. Eventually, I’ll probably order a complete system from Waldron’s and hope for better luck.

I just wanted to share my experience in case anyone else is considering one of these systems. Maybe others have had better luck, but based on my experience, I certainly wouldn’t recommend them and I will let as many Cadillac owners know on as many forums as I can find.

Has anyone here installed a Waldron exhaust system on a ‘64 Cadillac? I’d be interested to hear how the fit and sound compare to the original factory system.

Views: 2

Attachments:

▶ Reply to This

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

Forum

Replacement Exhaust System

Started by Tony Prichard in General Discussion 24 minutes ago. 0 Replies

Just wanted to share my experience with Classic Exhaust Systems out of Madison, Ohio. Unfortunately, it hasn’t been a good one.This isn’t my first time installing an exhaust system on a ‘64 Cadillac.…Continue

New Help Topic "AC/Heat: Blower Motors Used in 1963 & 1964" and Future Listings

Started by Jason Edge in General Discussion on Wednesday. 0 Replies

A lot has changed for me in the last year or so!With the help of Chat-GPT and a library of SIX Cadillac Master Parts Books, the 1963 and 1964 Shop Manuals, and a growing list if scanned and…Continue

64 RH front bumper bucket for sale.

Started by Russ Austin in General Discussion on Tuesday. 0 Replies

Is anyone looking for a 64 right side front bumper bucket?  Before I put it on ebay, I thought I would give the group a buzz first.Continue

Rescan of the Serviceman Bulletins Continues - Starting with January 1963

Started by Jason Edge in General Discussion. Last reply by Jason Edge on Saturday. 2 Replies

Way  back we had lower resolution JPG picture scans of the monthly Cadillac Serviceman Bulletins, and started rescanning the October and forward bulletins as higher 600dpi resolution searchable PDF…Continue

Blog Posts

Authenticity Manual

Posted by Dennis P. DiBari on August 27, 2026 at 12:45pm 2 Comments

Hi Robert,

     I emailed you more pictures for the Authenticity Manual.

Dennis DiBari

1963 RHS A/C kick panel - photos needed

Posted by SK on June 2, 2025 at 2:20pm 2 Comments

Could someone post front and back photos of the 1963 right-hand kick panel with A/C?

My car didn’t come with the original kick panels, so it's a bit of a mystery to me how I should cut the backing board and carpet to fit around the A/C.

Many thanks,

-Samu

'63 Tailfin Tales

Posted by Mark Mata on February 22, 2025 at 5:00pm 9 Comments

New old stock seat material

Posted by Ray Schick on August 22, 2024 at 6:25pm 2 Comments

I bought this seat material thinking that it’s…

Continue

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All

© 2026   Created by Jason Edge.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service